My dad used to ask odd riddles. (I would never do that to my kids…) One of the riddles went like this: How do you carve an elephant out of a block of wood? The answer is: You take a chisel to a block of wood and knock off anything that doesn’t look like an elephant.
As dumb as that it, it’s relevant in raising a family in today’s world. You have to know what your family is supposed to “look like” and knock off stuff that doesn’t look like that. I guess its also like driving a car; after a while things just look like they are supposed to. You can’t really explain why you stop before going through a green light, but something just doesn’t fit the normal and then a car runs a red light right in front of you.
This happened today for me with my daughter. Angelica has fought cancer, and now she is fighting to get back her strength and mobility. She wants a car, she wants a job, and most of all she just wants to be normal (at least as ‘normal’ as one of my kids can be).
She is taking a class at school called ‘Planning’. In this class they discuss all kinds of relevant stuff, like what skills will actually make you successful in the real world and how to think critically and how to prepare for a career and how to apply for a job. This part is awesome!!!
In teaching the class, her teacher wants everything to be ‘real’. He wants them to make resumes with skills that they actually have, select a job from the local paper that they might actually apply for, write a cover letter for their tailored resume as if they were actually applying for that job, and then conduct a mock interview where you explain why you want the job and what your qualifications are. This part is awesome!!!
The line was crossed for me when her teacher (name blurred to protect the well-meaning) told her that she couldn’t apply to be a “mother’s helper” because she can’t run after kids on a playground if they start to run away. Again, this is all in the name of making this exercise ‘real’, and I kind of understand the point. This went back and forth a little bit, but today Angelica got this note:
An alarm went off inside me… Now that I have processed it, written a response, received an apologetic call back from the teacher, I know perfectly well why this is bad, but I wrote the email before even fully thinking it through… I just knew it didn’t “look like an elephant”. Here is my reply:
As per attached, I do not agree with this and I want it to stop immediately!
Angelica has fought cancer with every fiber of her being for over three years. It has been one of the most difficult things that I have seen a child go through. Angelica was very athletic and was talking about signing up for baseball before she was diagnosed with cancer. The most painful part of the treatment for Angelica was what it stole from her in terms of time and opportunity. Now she is in a place of working very hard to recover and we are constantly reinforcing for her that she can do anything.
In an attempt to make this job interview as real as possible, I believe that you have crossed a very sensitive and very real personal boundary. The facts of her “medical condition” have only been discussed at length with Mrs — and Mr —. By repeatedly questioning Angelica’s “mother’s helper” job application and telling her that she couldn’t do that job, you are 1) incorrect about her condition, 2) incorrect about what a mother’s helper job is, 3) acting in a manner that will be harmful to her recovery, and 4) breaking the spirit of my daughter.
- Her condition is such that she should avoid running or doing major impact, but is completely capable of it if needs be. I don’t believe that its really her responsibility or requirement to provide you all the details of her condition to take this class. If she says that she can be a mother’s helper, then you are in no position to say otherwise.
- We have employed a couple mother’s helpers in the past and it did not always include taking care of children. A mother’s helper may be required to do household chores so the mother (who is still in the home) can spend time with their child. A mother’s helper is not the same as a nanny as a nanny is left alone with the child and chores. If Angelica applied to be a mother’s helper to our family, and I knew what I know about her capabilities, I would hire her in a heartbeat.
- Angelica needs motivation to do all the physio that she is required to do. Her motivation right now is that she wants to buy a car, and she needs a job to do that, and she is doing her physio as hard as possible so that she can get an actual job as soon as possible. By making her focus on limitations (that aren’t actually there) you are taking away her motivation.
- Angelica, who holds her emotion in to her own detriment, has broken down in tears about this. She is getting the message from this process that she is not good enough, that she is broken, that she could never get a job. My daughter has the spirit of a fighter, and in fact she has fought through cancer to live. But it took a lot of effort on the part of us, her parents, school counselors, friends, neighbors and family to constantly encourage her to fight, to win. I did not tolerate negative reinforcement then, and I will not tolerate it now.
I believe that walking the kids through real world scenarios is VERY VERY good. I wish that I had been taught what it is to apply for and compete for a job when I was in school. I understand the motivation for making it real, but I ask you to step back from the “realism” in this area.
I was impressed when I read my own email. The teacher called me right away, immediately saw my point and has set out to amend the situation. I wouldn’t always jump in to fight for my kids, but there are times when I do jump right away and I can’t really explain why… I just know what my family is supposed to look like and I’ll knock off anything that doesn’t look like it.
When do you jump in and fight for your kids, or let them fight for themselves?
love this! 🙂
i totally understand where you’re coming from though I think this would probably not be the first time Angelica would get a rejection. Not all people know her and what she has gone through.
I would actually welcome what the teacher did. However, I would also go to her and suggest another topic: “How to Manage Job Rejections”.
* last time I mean
Hi Riza, this is not a teacher rejecting her for a job in a mock interview, this is a personal note telling her that she is not capable of applying for the job in the first place… and the teacher does know what she has been through, doesnt know what the job really is and has no business talking to her about her medical issues as has been kept somewhat private at school. Dealing with rejection for a job is one thing. Having a teacher incorrectly argue with Angelica about whether she can handle kids is a different matter all together.
Well said Jonathan… I am proud of you. You are a good dad.
I was shocked to read the note and in tears by your response. Tears because a mother always knows best and I believe you did the right thing to fight for Angelica. Sadly kids are quick to be told they aren’t good enough and I can personally tell you that ‘not being good enough’ often makes its way into adulthood. Your family has been through enough over the last 3 years, the last thing you need is a teacher (of all people!) putting down your child. I’m glad to hear the teacher is making amends.
Love your reply to the teacher!! I think the teacher stepped over the line by writing that note. And yes, we do jump in and fight for our kids once they’ve tried problem solving on their own and it’s not going anywhere or getting resolved.
We’ve actually just had to do something very similar as you’ve had to do with our oldest daughter’s teacher.